Missing

Challenging the received wisdom

The good folk of Defra have asked Demos and Liverpool University to consider how lay people can play a part in expert scientific advice.

Social scientists have been saying for years that we need to think about expert advice differently. Thankfully, our project is being led by Alan Irwin and Kevin Jones at the University of Liverpool, who have been saying it better than most.

Having paddled upstream, we've now got the opportunity to see how things look in the murky world of evidence-based policy. The question is, when we can't get an ought from an is, and when it's sometimes not clear what the is is, how do we approach the complexities of knowledge and decisionmaking? I've got a short piece in the latest issue of Science and Public Affairs (what do you mean you don't read it?) looking at this with respect to the recent smoking ban.

With this project, I'm keen to make arguments about science and policy make sense to the people who work every day with the problem of knowing and doing - be they policymakers, doctors, scientists or experts. There's a lot of talk about public engagement with science, and a lot more about evidence-based policy. How can we do both at once?
The_received_wisdom
The Received Wisdom
Authors
Jack Stilgoe, Alan Irwin, Kevin Jones
Publication Date
2006-12-08
Publication Type
Pamphlet

The modern world needs experts. They are everywhere. In government, we are told that they are a resource – ‘on tap, not on top.’ But experience over the last 20 years, from BSE to MMR and beyond, has punctured the old, ‘speaking truth to power,’ model of expertise. The policy response to BSE has been to open up. But are we making the most of openness?

Dec 12

The expert patience programme

When you have a hammer of a pamphlet, every story looks like a nail. On Friday, we launched...

Oct 11

NICE drugs, if you can get them

Lead story on the breakfast news this morning was the battle between Alzheimer's patients...

Researchers